With several of the best reusable ice cream containers available to store everything you make in your ice cream maker, it can be tough finding the best ice cream container for your needs. If you’re someone who stores ice cream in large batches, you need to look for a container that is big and keeps the ice cream fresh. Homemade ice cream is great to enjoy, but you need to find the best ice cream container in order to keep your ice cream fresh in the freezer. Space can be at a premium in some freezers, making a half-gallon of ice cream a tight squeeze. Top 5 Ice Cream Storage Containers. We analyzed the leading Ice Cream Containers to help you find the best Ice Cream Container to buy. Our Top Four Ice Cream Containers Summer’s around the corner, it’s time to make your favorite homemade ice cream. To guarantee your treats are kept fresh you want quality tubs that fit into your freezer, offer tight-fitting lids, and are stackable to save room in your cupboards. An ideal ice cream tub needs to be deep and wide enough to hold at least 5-6 cups of ice cream.